Coleen Gottloeb

Cashiers Sotheby's International Realty
619 Hwy 107 South, Cashiers, NC 28717

Tel: 828-743-4611
Cell: 828-226-2227

Markets Served: Cashiers, NC;Glenville, North Carolina;Highlands, North Carolina;Sapphire, North Carolina;Cullowhee, North Carolina;

Specialties: Buyer's Specialist; Country Club Properties; Gated Communities; Golf; Listing Specialist; Mountain Properties; Residential Lots; Resort/Vacation; Waterfront/Waterview;

What do Clients Say?

"We bought our house from Coleen 20 years ago and we have had 20 wonderful years in it. She knew exactly what we were looking for and we only looked at three homes. Now that she is Broker-In-Charge, everyone there is so lucky to have her! She is everything you would want in a Sales Person & Broker.”

Connie F.

About Coleen

Coleen is the Broker-In-Charge at Cashiers Sotheby's International Realty.

With over 25 years of real estate experience in the Cashiers area, Coleen is excited to be a part of The McKee Group brokered by Cashiers Sotheby's International Realty and carry on as the Broker-In-Charge. As a seasoned Broker she has crafted a career out of transforming the seemingly ordinary into the extraordinary. Helping to unite buyers and sellers in pursuit of their desires and dreams.

But it's not just about the numbers and deals. Her true passion lies in forging connections, understanding the unique aspirations of each client and transforming their vision into a tangible reality. She prides herself on being not just a Broker, but a trusted confidant and advisor throughout the entire process.

Coleen joined McKee Properties in 2017 as Broker-in-Charge. Serving as the company’s chief administrative officer, she oversees day-to-day operations, from reviewing contracts and agreements to supporting Brokers’ professional development and continuing education. Additionally, she serves as the company’s primary liaison to state and local real estate professional organizations.


A native of St. Cloud in central Florida, Coleen holds a bachelor of science in marketing from Florida State University, making her a third-generation Seminole. She earned her NC real estate license in 1996. Her professional designations include Certified Residential Specialist (CRS); Graduate, REALTOR® Institute (GRI); Green; Resort & Second-Home Property Specialist (RSPS); Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES); and a member of the Institute for Luxury Home Marketing.


Coleen and her late husband Miles moved to the area in 1995 — making a “dream come true.” Prior to joining Cashiers Sotheby's International Realty, she served three other real estate companies in Cashiers.


She serves on the Board of Directors for the Highlands-Cashiers Multiple Listing Service and is a member of Friends of Lake Glenville, Cashiers Historical Society and Friends of Panthertown.


Coleen has one son — Jake, a Western Carolina University graduate, currently working for the Southwestern Commission. An avid outdoors woman, Coleen enjoys traveling, hiking, boating, biking, camping and her newly-discovered sport, kayaking. She can also be found bowling, making pottery or taking in a movie.