Justin Croy

I Provide ~ You Decide

eXp Realty
Reel Keeper Home Team
11512 Lake Mead Ave, Suite 704, Jacksonville, FL 32256


Tel: 904-414-4000
Cell: 904-803-7897

Markets Served: Jacksonville Beach, Florida;Atlantic Beach, Florida;Neptune Beach, Florida;Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida;Ponte Vedra, Florida;

Specialties: Athletes/Celebrities; Buyer's Specialist; Country Club Properties; Gated Communities; Golf; Marina/Boating; New Homes; Sporting (tennis, fishing); Waterfront/Waterview;

What do Clients Say?

We recently listed and sold our home with Justin and the Reel Keeper team. This was our second time working with Justin, but our first selling experience. We were impressed with Justin's in-depth marketing strategy and expert advice. Throughout the process, communication was always prompt, clear, and concise. The experience was smooth and we believe hiring Justin resulted in a higher selling price for our home. We will always do business with Justin and his team in the future.

John Fisher

Our experience with Justin was amazing. Over the course of months my wife and I were looking for a house we could call a home. This being our first house, of course, we were a little too cautious and weary of just going with any house we liked. It absolutely had to be perfect! Justin stuck with us throughout the experience, taking in what we liked, what we loved, and what we hated and finally found our perfect home. Justin was great at explaining the process and making sure we weren't taken advantage of being a first time homebuyer. We was able to negotiate everything we asked and did it with a smile on his face. I would recommend him for any young family looking to find a home.

Jon McNemar

Justin and the Reel Keeper Home Team did an excellent job in selling our house. Everything from help to stage it, going over timelines on preparing the listing and going through the multiple showings and offers that we received. That service continued from from the acceptance of the offer to the closing. I highly recommend them if you are looking to buy or sell a home.

Ben Balke

Justin helped me search for my perfect home for over 9 months. Being a sellers market, he was always on the ball, sending me new listings before they even hit the market! That’s how I eventually found it! And it’s the perfect home for me! Thank you, Justin, for always being there for me, being professional every step of the way, and guiding me through the process from beginning to end. I couldn’t have done it without you!

Aimee Karaitis

I was connected to Justin by a friend in Atlanta. He was quick to make contact with my husband and I and showed us the first home within a couple of days. The home did not check all the boxes, but Justin carefully listened to our needs and quickly followed this showing with five quality listings. We found our dream home and he was instrumental in us doing so!!! He is incredibly knowledgeable, and negotiated when needed to ensure we got what we wanted! This process was frictionless and that is hard to say when purchasing a home. We are incredibly thankful to Justin and I highly recommend him to any and all!!!

Melissa Baker

About Justin

I'm born & raised in Jacksonville, I've always excelled in academics and sports and I like to win. I graduated from Florida State University specializing in Real Estate and I come from a Real Estate family with a vast background in Real Estate. Growing up, my family has always been about giving back and helping others, which has given me a foundation for success. Knowing the importance of superior customer service and the art of listening, I'm extremely driven to exceeding my buyers and sellers expectations. Its not about what you can do for yourselve but rather what you can do for others. As a Real Etate Professional, I have the ability to do just that so let me know when I can help you navigate your home selling or home buying process!