Toby Kreiselmaier

Where North Georgia's Mountains Meet Uncommon Expertise

What do Clients Say?

Toby went above and beyond for us as we only had 2 days to find a cabin and he delivered which allowed us to close in 3 weeks! Toby stays with on top of everything we need and also offers thoughtful ideas for getting upgrades completed. He doesn’t waste time and always answers your call or calls you back within the hour. If you’re looking for a fantastic agent look no further. He and his wife are amazing!

Michael Mooney & Rakhshinda Moeen

His patience is unmatched. No matter how many questions and showings we had (and we had a lot!), he always took the time to explain things clearly and never made us feel rushed. He guided us calmly through the stressful parts and celebrated with us in the exciting moments. As the Germans would say, ‘Geduld bringt Rosen’ (patience brings roses)—and in our case, it brought us not just one success, but two! We couldn’t recommend Toby more highly.

Helene Trowell & Edward Levert

He’s incredibly knowledgeable about the community and broader Ellijay area, lined up multiple properties for us to compare, and guided us through each step with clear, timely communication. He made the process easy and low-stress, and we’d recommend him without hesitation to anyone buying land, planning to build, or purchasing a home in North Georgia.

Ken & Shannon Shelley

He asked a lot of detailed questions and made sure he understood exactly what we were looking for. He (and Jessica!) made time to meet us that weekend, just two days later, at lots we were interested in and he got us set upon the email list for land immediately, which was very helpful. And road snacks were included on the lot looking days and that was SO thoughtful of you guys. I LOVED the personalized map and list that was made for us. He was very thorough going through all of the paperwork with us and made sure we had no questions left unanswered. He was always very reachable and responsive. 10 out 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Tara Downor & Charles Garrett

The photos were absolutely stunning — and the drone footage was the icing on the cake, showcasing our property in a way standard photos never could. What could have been a stressful process ended up feeling easy and well-guided. Toby was patient, took the time to answer every question, and helped us understand each step along the way. When it came time to buy, he showed us countless homes across multiple areas until we found exactly what we wanted. His honesty, local knowledge, and thoughtful opinions made all the difference. By the end of the process, we didn’t just have a realtor — we had a friend. We highly recommend Toby to anyone buying or selling in the North Georgia mountains. He’s the realtor everyone needs in this area!

Richard & Sharon Evans

About Toby

Located in the Blue Ridge foothills of Ellijay, Georgia, Toby Kreiselmaier brings a rare combination of intellect, integrity, and instinct to the marketing and sale of the region's most distinguished properties. As an Associate Broker with RE/MAX Town & Country and a Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist, he serves discerning buyers and sellers seeking not just a home, but a way of life — mountain retreats with sweeping ridge views, riverfront estates, and private sanctuaries tucked into the beautiful landscape.

Toby approaches every client relationship with a depth of listening and discernment uncommon in the industry — understanding that a luxury property purchase is rarely just a transaction, but often a decision tied to legacy, family, and personal meaning. This thoughtful, client-first philosophy has earned him a reputation as an out-of-the-box thinker who crafts distinctive marketing narratives for every listing, elevating each property beyond its square footage to tell the story of the life it makes possible.

As founder and Vice President of the North Georgia Mountains BNI chapter, Toby has cultivated a trusted network of the area's finest professionals — designers, property specialists, and craftsmen — ensuring clients are supported by a seamless team from first showing to final closing. Whether guiding a family to their forever mountain home or representing a landmark North Georgia property, Toby combines local expertise, technology-forward marketing, and genuine care to deliver an experience as exceptional as the properties themselves.

Discover what's possible in the North Georgia Mountains — where luxury meets legacy.